These oral proficiency marking criteria are based on IATEFL criteria and the Canadian Language Benchmarks. They describe speaking ability in terms of:

1.      Range: vocabulary, grammar.
2.       Ease of speech: fluency.
3.       Attitude: self-confidence, motivation, reduced anxiety/nervousness.
4.       Delivery: volume, pronunciation, intonation, word-stress, speech-rhythm.
5.       Interaction: body language, communication strategies, social conversation skills.

Are you READI? Then let¡¯s begin!

The Peer-assess charts (following pages) have marks from 1 to 4.
Each mark tells us how the READI criteria affect communication:

R (1): The student¡¯s low range makes communication difficult.

  • Not enough range (words and phrases) for the speaking task.
  • Almost no control of basic grammar (sentence structure and verb tenses)
  • Communication does not continue.

R (2): The student¡¯s range almost supports communication

  • Almost enough range for the speaking task. (some vocabulary and simple phrases).
  • Little control of grammar structures/tenses.
  • Information transfer problems may occur.

R (3): The student¡¯s range supports communication

  • Enough range for the speaking task.
  • Some control of basic structures and tenses.
  • Errors occur but communication continues.

R (4): The student¡¯s range enhances communication

  • Enough range to perform the speaking task effectively and easily.
  • Control of basic grammar and tenses.

 

E (1): The student¡¯s low fluency makes communication difficult.

  • The student speaks after long delays.
  • Often repeats the words.
  • Depends on body-gestures.
  • Uses single words or groups of 2 to 3 words.
  • No connected discourse.

E (2): The student¡¯s ease of speech almost supports communication

  • Makes pauses and depends on gestures.
  • Uses single words and short sentences.
  • Can ask and reply to simple questions.
  • Some connected discourse.

E (3): The student¡¯s ease of speech supports communication

  • Some short delays before speaking.
  • Can ask and reply to WH questions.
  • Evidence of connected discourse (and, but).
  • Errors occur but communication continues.

E (4): The student¡¯s ease of speech enhances communication

  • Little or no delay before speaking.
  • Uses a variety of short sentences.
  • Clearly connected discourse (and, but, first, next, then, because).
  • Communication flows at smooth pace
  • Uses highly appropriate language.

 

A (1): The student¡¯s poor attitude makes communication difficult.

  • Little or no enthusiasm for communication.
  • Lack of confidence/motivation.
  • High anxiety/nervousness
  • Communication does not continue.

A (2): The student¡¯s attitude almost supports communication

  • Some desire to perform the task.
  • Lack of confidence/ motivation.
  • Anxiety and/or nervousness.
  • Communication can be difficult.

A (3): The student¡¯s attitude supports communication

  • Positive attitude towards communication.
  • Desire to achieve the communication goal.
  • Confidence/motivation/anxiety/nervousness do not prevent communication.

A (4): The student¡¯s attitude enhances communication

  • Enthusiasm and positive attitude.
  • The student encourages others.
  • The student is confident and motivated.

 

D (1): The student¡¯s poor delivery makes communication difficult.

  • May use first language at times.
  • Pronunciation difficulties and low volume.
  • The speech may be uncomfortably slow.
  • The voice tends to be monotone

D (2): The student¡¯s delivery almost supports communication

  • Some pronunciation difficulties
  • Low volume, poor intonation
  • Poor word stress and speech rhythm
  • Communication can be difficult.

D (3): The student¡¯s delivery supports communication

  • Occasional pronunciation difficulties.
  • Delivery (stress, intonation, pronunciation, volume, speech-rhythm) allows communication to continue.

D (4): The student¡¯s delivery enhances communication

  • Few pronunciation difficulties.
  • Use of appropriate ¡®voice¡¯ (stress, intonation, pronunciation, volume, speech-rhythm) enhances communication.

 

I (1): The student¡¯s poor interaction makes communication difficult.

  • The student speaks very little, and only in response to the others.
  • No attempt to keep the communication going.
  • Needs much help from the other students.
  • Lack of body language or communication strategies.

I (2): The student¡¯s interaction almost supports communication

  • Tries to keep the communication going.
  • Needs frequent assistance.
  • Can communicate in a limited way.

I (3): The student¡¯s interaction supports communication

  • Sometimes needs assistance.
  • Shows an awareness of being a part of an interactive social situation.
  • Uses body language and verbal cues. 
  • Shows interest in what others are saying.

I (4): The student¡¯s interaction enhances communication

  • Active in an interactive social situation.
  • Body language is pro-communicative.
  • Encourages others to communicate.
  • Checks that he/she understands and that others understand him/her.